When you’ve been diagnosed with mesothelioma or asbestos lung cancer, and you hope to get justice from the companies that exposed you to asbestos, you need to convince a jury that your accusations are true. While your medical records and work history form the foundation of your case, expert witnesses often provide the crucial testimony that transforms evidence into a compelling argument for liability and compensation.
The History of Using Expert Witnesses in Court
While expert witnesses now play an accepted and expected role in legal proceedings, this was not always the case. The use of expert witnesses only developed over the past 250 years. Previously, courts relied on special juries composed of people with relevant expertise, and judges used specialist advisors.[1]
The landmark 1782 case of Folkes v. Chadd, decided by Lord Mansfield, established that experts could provide opinion evidence based on facts in areas requiring specialized knowledge. The case involved harbor engineering, and Mansfield ruled that “in matters of science no other witnesses can be called,” allowing an engineer to testify despite not having personally viewed the site around which the case revolved. Soon after this, medical expert witnesses began to be accepted. In 18th-century London homicide trials, fewer than half included medical testimony or autopsy reports, but by the late 19th century, medical evidence appeared in over 90% of cases. Courts permitted medical opinions on the causes of wounds, and whether a specific injury could lead to death.
Though respected today, through much of the 19th century, expert witnesses were criticized as biased partisans. Critics asserted that they were paid to support whoever hired them, and this skepticism persisted and led to modern standards of expert witness admissibility. The 1923 ruling in Frye v. United States was pivotal to these standards, requiring “general acceptance” of scientific methods, and in 1993, Daubert v. Merrell Dow Pharmaceuticals established that expert testimony must be based on sufficient data, reliable methods, and proper application of principles. Federal Rule 702 now governs expert admissibility, requiring that expert knowledge help fact-finders understand evidence through testimony grounded in reliable scientific, technical, or specialized principles.[1]
What Expert Witnesses Do in Mesothelioma Cases
Expert witnesses are professionals with specialized knowledge, training, or experience in fields relevant to a legal case. Unlike fact witnesses who testify about what they personally observed, expert witnesses provide professional opinions based on their expertise.[2]
In mesothelioma litigation, expert witness testimony serves several important functions:
- It establishes the medical connection between asbestos exposure and your diagnosis
- It identifies likely sources of your asbestos exposure based on your work history
- It explains complex medical and scientific concepts to judges and jurors
- It counters the opposing expert testimony presented by the defendants
- It calculates the economic impact of your illness, including medical costs and lost earning capacity
Expert testimony often makes the difference between a successful claim and one that’s dismissed. This is especially true when defendants dispute the source of exposure or challenge the causal link between their products and your disease.
Types of Expert Witnesses in Asbestos Cases
Mesothelioma lawsuits typically require testimony from several types of experts. Each addresses different aspects of your claim.
Medical Experts
Medical experts, usually oncologists or pulmonologists specializing in asbestos-related diseases, provide testimony about your diagnosis, prognosis, and treatment needs. These physicians explain how asbestos fibers cause mesothelioma, detail the progression of your disease, and discuss your life expectancy and quality of life.
When a medical expert is hired to assess your case, they will review your pathology reports, imaging studies, and treatment records, and then offer professional opinions about your condition. They also establish that your mesothelioma resulted specifically from asbestos exposure rather than other causes, countering any defense arguments about alternative explanations for your illness.
Industrial Hygienists
Industrial hygienists are experts in workplace safety and occupational health hazards. In mesothelioma cases, they analyze your employment history to identify when, where, and how you were exposed to asbestos.
These experts review historical records about asbestos use in various industries, workplaces, and products. They can testify about the types of asbestos-containing materials present at your job sites, the conditions under which you worked, and whether adequate safety measures were in place to protect workers.
Industrial hygienists often reconstruct exposure scenarios, explaining to the jury how common workplace activities—insulating pipes, installing ceiling tiles, working near others handling asbestos materials—can result in asbestos fiber inhalation. Their testimony is particularly valuable when your exposure occurred decades ago, and physical evidence no longer exists.
Occupational Exposure Experts
Similar to industrial hygienists, occupational exposure experts specialize in identifying asbestos exposure sources. These professionals often have backgrounds in specific industries—construction, shipbuilding, manufacturing, or military service—where asbestos use was prevalent.
For veterans with mesothelioma, military exposure experts can testify about asbestos presence on Navy ships, in barracks, or at military installations where you served. They understand the duties associated with various military occupational specialties and can explain which roles involved direct or secondary asbestos exposure.
These experts frequently consult databases, historical documents, and product identification resources to pinpoint the specific asbestos-containing materials a mesothelioma victim has encountered during their career.
Toxicology and Pathology Experts
Toxicologists explain how asbestos fibers interact with human tissue at a cellular level, and how they cause the genetic changes that lead to mesothelioma. Their testimony helps juries understand the biological mechanisms behind asbestos diseases.
Pathologists examine tissue samples and can identify the type of asbestos fibers present in your lungs or pleural tissue. Since different industries used different types of asbestos, fiber identification can sometimes help trace exposure back to specific defendants.
Economic Experts
Economic experts calculate the financial impact of your mesothelioma diagnosis. They quantify lost wages, diminished earning capacity, and future medical costs, providing concrete dollar amounts to help the jury determine the economic damages to be included in their verdict.
These experts consider your age, education, work history, and career trajectory to determine what you would have earned absent your disease. They also project lifetime medical costs based on your treatment plan and life expectancy. Their testimony is meant to ensure that your settlement or verdict covers your ongoing needs.
How Expert Witnesses Strengthen Your Mesothelioma Case
The right expert witnesses can transform a complex mesothelioma case into a clear narrative that resonates with judges and juries.[3]
Establishing Causation
One of the biggest challenges in mesothelioma litigation is proving that a specific defendant’s asbestos-containing product caused the victim’s illness. Given the long latency period—often 20 to 50 years between exposure and diagnosis—and the reality that most victims had multiple exposures throughout their careers, establishing causation requires expert analysis.
Medical experts testify that asbestos exposure is the only known cause of mesothelioma, eliminating alternative explanations for your disease. Industrial hygienists and exposure experts then connect your diagnosis to specific work sites, products, or defendants, creating a clear chain of causation from exposure to illness.
Overcoming Defense Arguments
Defendants in asbestos cases typically deploy their own expert witnesses to challenge a mesothelioma victim’s claims. They may argue that the exposure cited was too minimal to cause disease, that the mesothelioma resulted from other sources, or that their products didn’t contain asbestos when the victim encountered them.
Expert witnesses counter these defense arguments with scientific evidence and professional opinions. An industrial hygienist might present historical documents proving asbestos content in a defendant’s products. A medical expert might explain that even brief asbestos exposure can cause mesothelioma, particularly with certain fiber types.
This battle of experts often determines case outcomes, making their credibility essential.
Educating Judges and Juries
Mesothelioma cases involve complex medical, scientific, and industrial processes that most jurors don’t encounter in their everyday lives. Expert witnesses serve as teachers, translating technical information into language that the average listener can understand.
A pulmonologist might use photos or drawings to show how asbestos fibers lodge in lung tissue. An industrial hygienist might demonstrate the dusty conditions in a shipyard or construction site. Their explanations help juries visualize the victim’s experience and understand why their asbestos exposure was significant.
Effective expert testimony also creates an emotional connection while simultaneously maintaining scientific credibility. This balance can significantly strengthen a legal argument.
Documenting Exposure When Records Are Limited
Many mesothelioma victims worked for companies that no longer exist, at job sites that have been demolished, or with products that manufacturers discontinued decades ago. When direct evidence of exposure isn’t unavailable, expert reconstruction becomes crucial.
Exposure experts can testify about industry-standard practices during the years that the victim worked, explaining what materials were commonly used and how workers handled them. They consult historical records, safety data sheets, and industry publications to recreate the conditions that the victim faced.
For lawsuits filed by veterans, military exposure experts can access documentation specific to the ships they served on, Army base records, and other military sources to establish asbestos presence during their time of service. This documentation is particularly valuable when proving exposure that occurred 30 or 40 years ago.
Finding Qualified Expert Witnesses for Your Case
The success of a mesothelioma claim depends significantly on the quality of the expert witnesses who are called to provide testimony. Experienced asbestos attorneys maintain professional relationships with respected experts who have testified in numerous cases and whose credentials can withstand scrutiny.
If you have been diagnosed with mesothelioma and have elected to pursue an asbestos claim, your legal team will select experts with:
- Advanced degrees and certifications in relevant fields
- Extensive experience with asbestos-related diseases or industrial exposures
- Strong publication records in peer-reviewed journals
- Proven courtroom testimony experience
- No conflicts of interest that defense attorneys can exploit
- The ability to communicate complex concepts clearly and persuasively
Top-tier experts command significant fees, but their testimony can increase settlement values substantially or secure jury verdicts that compensate you fully for your losses.
The Expert Witness Process in Mesothelioma Litigation
Understanding what expert witnesses do can help you appreciate what is involved in building a strong asbestos claim.
Case Review and Evaluation
After you hire an attorney, your legal team will identify which experts’ knowledge will best match your case. Medical experts will review your diagnosis and treatment records, while exposure experts will analyze your work history and employment documentation. Economic experts will examine your financial records and earning history.
Each expert will provide your attorney with a preliminary opinion about your case’s strengths and weaknesses. This helps your attorney develop their litigation strategy.
Report Preparation
After a preliminary report, an expert witness will typically prepare detailed written reports summarizing their findings and opinions. These reports cite scientific literature, historical documents, and other sources supporting their conclusions. Defense attorneys receive copies of these reports during the discovery process, allowing them to prepare their counterarguments.
Well-documented expert reports can sometimes prompt a quick settlement negotiation, as defendants recognize the strength of your evidence and choose not to take a case to trial.
Depositions
The defendants’ attorneys will depose your expert witnesses, asking them detailed questions about their qualifications, methodology, and opinions. These depositions serve several purposes: they lock experts into their testimony, reveal the basis for their opinions, and allow defense counsel to identify potential weaknesses.
Experienced experts handle aggressive deposition questioning professionally, maintaining their credibility while defending their conclusions.
Trial Testimony
If your case goes to trial, your attorneys will present the experts to the court to testify before the jury. Each witness will explain their qualifications, describe their analysis of your case, and offer their professional opinions about your exposure, diagnosis, and damages.
Defense attorneys have the opportunity to cross-examine your experts, and will attempt to undermine their credibility or create doubt about their conclusions. Strong experts maintain their composure and respond to challenges effectively, leaving juries confident in their testimony.
The Cost of Expert Witnesses and Who Pays
Expert witness fees can be substantial, particularly in complex mesothelioma cases requiring multiple specialists. Medical experts might charge several thousand dollars for case review and testimony. Nationally recognized industrial hygienists command premium rates for their services.[3]
Fortunately, most mesothelioma attorneys work on a contingency basis, advancing all case costs, including expert witness fees. You pay nothing upfront, and your attorney recoups these costs only if your case succeeds. This arrangement allows you to access top-tier experts regardless of your financial situation.
When evaluating settlements or jury awards, remember that expert witness costs will be deducted from your recovery. However, the increased compensation these experts help secure typically far exceeds their fees.
Working With Your Legal Team and Experts
The crucial testimony that expert witnesses provide begins with the information provided to them by the victim. To ensure that your attorney chooses the right expert, you need to provide complete employment records, including dates, locations, job duties, and employers. The more detailed your work history, the easier it is for exposure experts to identify asbestos source, even if you can’t remember specific details. Exposure experts can often fill gaps in your memory using historical research and industry knowledge. Similarly, if you served in the military, be sure to provide information about your branch, duties, locations, and the vessels or units where you served.
Share all medical records and treatment information with your legal team promptly. Medical experts need comprehensive documentation to support their opinions about your diagnosis and prognosis.
Finally, trust your attorney’s judgment about which experts to retain and how to present your case. Experienced mesothelioma lawyers understand which expert combinations create the most persuasive arguments for your specific circumstances.
The Impact of Expert Testimony on Settlements and Verdicts
Cases with strong expert witness testimony typically settle for higher amounts or result in larger jury verdicts than cases lacking expert support, and when it comes to settlements, defendants’ attorneys recognize when plaintiffs have assembled credible, experienced experts whose testimony is likely to persuade a jury. When they face nationally recognized experts with impeccable credentials and persuasive testimony styles, settlement values increase significantly.
If your case goes to trial, expert testimony often determines the outcome. Juries facing conflicting expert opinions generally side with the witnesses they find more credible, more qualified, and more persuasive. The difference between winning and losing your case frequently comes down to which side presented better experts.
Mesothelioma Attorney Work with Top-Notch Expert Witnesses
If you’ve been diagnosed with mesothelioma or asbestos lung cancer, working with an experienced mesothelioma attorney should be your next priority after arranging for medical care. Knowledgeable asbestos attorneys have long-standing relationships with respected expert witnesses and the resources to build comprehensive cases on your behalf.
The sooner you contact an attorney, the sooner experts can begin analyzing your case, identifying exposure sources, and developing the testimony that will support your claim for compensation. Expert witnesses provide the professional credibility and scientific evidence that transforms your personal experience into a legally compelling case for the compensation you deserve.
References
View All References
